Thursday, August 3, 2017

Americans Want To Ban Brave New World?

     While browsing through the Internet I began to read articles about certain books that Americans have been constantly petitioning for schools to ban simply because they discussed material that is not suited for students to read. Among the list I found that Suzanne Collins's book the Hunger Games, and Stephanie Meyer's bestseller Twilight were on the list, and making it into the top ten ranking in third place was Aldous Huxley's Brave New World. According to the article it states that " The novel of a dystopian future was one of the most complained about books in America last year, with readers protesting over its sexually explicit scenes, "offensive" language and "insensitivity"[...]in 1980 it was removed from classrooms for making promiscuous sex "look like fun", and it has been the subject of frequent challenges in the US over the years." However despite the total of 808 reports in effort to take down the novel off of book shelves in America, their challenges go unreported, and have been ignored by the American Library Association in order to " protect one of the most precious of our fundamental rights – the freedom to read", the article states. 
    
     I believe that books similar to Brave New World shouldn't be banned because it serves as a platform of not only discussing it's interesting dark message with fellow peers but also understanding the concept of racial, and intellectual superiority. Which sadly some people still have that mindset today. What are your views of people wanting to ban not only Brave New World, but other books too that help young readers to better understand more serious topics of discussion? 

-Nathalie Gonzalez

4 comments:

  1. I do believe a book such as Brave New World should not be read by young children since it does involve explicit material, but the meaning goes so much deeper into that and it would be immature to think that sex and language are only reasons that the book shouldn't be read by any students. There is a lot of analysis and symbolism that ties into the story, and it is so relevant to society nowadays. The novel's topic of sex is to actually teach people that a society should never get to the point that sex is meaningless and done with many people. In my opinion, if a younger person were to read Brave New World, they would need to look up or have someone help them comprehend what the story involves, just like we are doing.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While some of these books mention some explicit things that a young child shouldn't read, they're not solely based on those details. There's way more to the plot than the explicit details that are contained in the pages. Like, for example, a few months ago they were trying to ban schools from reading To Kill A Mockingbird because of one explicit word that's used. What they don't see beyond these details, the plots have way deeper meaning to them that teaches us many things not just about us, but also our world today. So, yes there are some details that are way to explicit for a young child to understand, but that shouldn't be the main focus to ban them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The adults who try to ban books like Brave New World do not understand that a majority of the kids who read it are old enough to understand that certain actions done by the characters are not right. It almost feels as if they forgot that they were our age once. But, I do believe that younger audiences should not read it. To be realistic, what kid would pick up a book like Brave New World? The older ones would probably read the back and think that it is boring. I know I would. The younger ones are usually more focused on the appearance of the book and would not read it because it looks boring or is too hard for them to understand (if they even try). A majority of the adults who are protesting have probably never even read the books you mentioned. They most likely saw the movie and did not like the violence (for the books that were turned into movies). If the adults ever read them, they would know that these books are decent for kids our age. They would know that the protesting is ridiculous.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I don't think that people should ban books that are similar to Brave New World because then, children would have a hard time adapting to society and what not to do in it. For instance, the alphas are above the deltas in their society, but in our society, we are considered equal. You can't just say things like, "White people are better than everyone!" It's just rude. These kind of books can teach you not to say those kinds of things.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.