I'm just over halfway through Sherry Turkle's Alone Together: Why We Expect More from Technology and Less from Each Other, and I came across a passage that perplexed me to some extent. On the topic of texting, Turkle writes:
"These days, as a continuous stream of texts becomes a way of life, we may say less to each other because we imagine that what we say is almost already a throwaway. Texts, by nature telegraphic, can certainly be emotional, insightful, and sexy. They can lift us up. They can make us feel understood, desired, and supported. But they are not a place to deeply understand a problem or to explain a complicated situation. They are momentum. They fill a moment" (168).
I had difficulty relating to and understanding this passage personally. I felt the way she describes texting contradicts her overall standpoint about it and thus makes it difficult to understand. How can we feel truly "understood" or "supported" in our endeavors without having explained through the texts our "complicated situations" and personal problems to the person on the receiving end at all? Moreover, when I text with my close friends, I have observed that most of time we start off in the conversation at an emotional high, feeling overwhelmed and usually not really knowing yet the root cause for what we are feeling. Talking about it through text, we are still able to delve into our problems and analyze ourselves and our emotions. We identify and reach a conclusion by the end and aim to better our predicament by what we've learned, or if we haven't, we leave knowing we have support from the person on the other end of the line, who's ready to pick up the conversation where it left off the next time you are.
I found Turkle's standpoint subjective. Texting has the potential to help us therapeutically the way writing in a journal and talking to loved ones does. I think the reaches of texting depends a lot on who you talk to and yourself as well. Maybe I'm missing something she's trying to say, and perhaps other standpoints will help me better understand her or better believe my position. How do you guys interpret this passage? Is your point of view similar to hers or mine, or do you have one of your own? Do you agree, disagree, or partially agree or disagree, and why or why not?
As a kid who grew up in the generation of technology she talks about, I feel that I have a bias as well, but this is just what I've known. I'd like to hear what others have to say on this subject matter.
Tabby Verayo
I am at a midpoint on this situation, I don't fully agree but I also don't fully disagree on the matter. Yes, sometimes you can never resolve a situation all through a text message, it all depends on how serious the problem is. Sometimes it's better to confront it face to face if it's really serious because we don't always mean what we say in a text. We don't really get to see the other person's true emotions through our phones, words can be just words. However, talking about these things in person, you get a deeper connection since you're talking about it and you're letting what you feel inside right out. On the other hand, some problems we go through aren't as serious and it can easily be resolved through a message because we may think it's simple that it doesn't need to be talked about face to face. It still makes us feel heard and understood to our friends on the other line, that still makes that connection grow stronger either way. So, it all depends on the problems and emotions we talk about and the seriousness of them that helps us connect, whether through a text or person.
ReplyDeleteTexting is a way, as you said before, to theuraputically help us "talk" about our problems with someone who is willing to listen. There's always alternative options to texting, such as calling or video messaging (skype and facetime). I personally believe if there is something important that I want to talk about then i'll save it till I meet the person at another time. However, if you as an indivdual believe it's something that you need to talk about and are unable to see them right away. Then facetiming is a great way to deal with your emotions and dilemmas before it settles as a burden on your shoulders. There are moments in time where we cannot be with someone to delve in our problems. I understand the controversy about showing out emotions through texts isn't as sympathetic as being in each others prescence. However, we have multiple modern ways of communication which can help us take a step back an analyze how we could move past or fix the situation at hand, by discussing with a companion. As our society continues to advance technologically, there will always be postives and negatives aspects. Which is why we must keep in mind Postman's statements, on how we must be educated on the major affects of technology and it's influence on our daily lives/future generations.
ReplyDeleteI see what Turkle means by texts not holding the full potential of support compared to a conversation in person. Texts can be interpreted in varying ways than what you might have meant it to be. For example, a text in all caps can be misrepresented as someone who is angry due to the text being seen as someone who is shouting. That probably didn't make any sense, sorry. What I mean is that a simple text can be interpreted in differentiating tones such as an irritated, angry, or sarcastic one. All of those have negative connotations, but I'm not saying that all misread texts are in a bad way. Anyways, back to the topic. I agree with you in the sense that texts do allow people access to unload their feelings and thoughts but in my opinion it doesn't have the same effect as a one on one conversation does. Maybe it's the fact that visually, typed words aren't enough because they don't hold the emotion or empathy the person's voice and facial expressions would. That's just me because usually I would liberate my intital feelings of grief and what not then save the rest for later when I see the person. Otherwise, as Krystal has mentioned, face timing is also a good alternative.
ReplyDeleteI more strongly support the view that texting is a good and effective method of communication, but it's downfalls are quite obvious as well. I often use texting as a way to keep in touch with friends and to let my emotions out to the people I feel comfortable with. I often use texting because I am not allowed to make calls which is why I support this method of communication. I do, however, believe that talking face to face or making calls are more effective and give an extra sense of connection between the two people because they can see each other's facial expresssions and hear their tones of voices. It gives a stronger emotional connection than that of texting. Although it is ideal to talk to someone in person or over a phone call, I believe texting is a good way to at least keep in touch and let your friends get a general idea of how you're feeling.
ReplyDeleteI wholeheartedly agree with what you say. I'm also not allowed to make video calls like FaceTime unless under certain conditions or go out to see people a lot, so texting is usually the next best thing if I feel like I need to talk to someone. However, as you, Chelsy, Krystal, and Raqsmey mentioned, it has its obvious limitations. It's more difficult to speak figuratively and convey the right feelings with certain phrases sometimes. Above all, of course I'd prefer being face to face when talking to someone or even through video call as everything would be more authentic, real, up close and personal. But with limitations like the ones we have, texting can still provide opportunity to talk depending on how it's used. All of you make excellent points.
Delete