After reading Brave New World by Aldous Huxley, it disturbed me that even though the society in the book is considered to be "utopian", there are still problems that shouldn't make the society be considered utopian. I realized that what made the society in the story utopian is that everyone is brainwashed by the government. If everyone wasn't told what their role is in the beginning of their lifetime, then everyone would basically be the same caste, and some would be angry if they were given a job lower in importance than another, much important, job given to another person. The leaders in this society want comfort in every individual's life, so they forced every individual to believe and do the role of the caste they were given when decanted. People who didn't follow their role of their caste or don't follow the laws of society, they basically understand the reality of life and would suffer a world somewhat dystopian for being someone different.
This made me realize that utopian societies, in general, aren't really utopian societies, but are dystopian societies in disguise. A utopian society would make people feel comfort if the government controlled the life of every individual; for example, a government would have to control the social class, laws, and lifestyle of every individual. The controlling of the government to civilians is basically a totalitarian government, and what doesn't make civilians in a totalitarian government in a utopian world upset about this idea is that they are being brainwashed, thinking that this type of government is good. Individuals in a utopian society would realize the society actually being dystopian if they break the rules and don't follow their role in society, which would cause them to realize how everyone is acting strange because the government is controlling them.
Bernard, John, and Helmholtz were the only ones in their society to realize how everyone is under the control of the government, which makes them see how dystopian the society actually is. Utopian societies aren't really a hundred percent comfortable because there would be some way that would make someone want to see the reality of their society, which would make them see the society in a very depressing way.
Liliana Carrera
In the first sentence, you stated that the society in the novel is considered to be a Utopian society, but you noticed reasons why it isn't. So, who are you saying considers it to be a Utopian society? I personally thought it was a dystopian society as soon as Bernard was introduced, and throughout the novel more and more reasons lead me to believe it was a dystopian society. Also, most websites that I've looked at regarding the book stated it was a dystopian society, so who is it you're referring to that considers it to be a utopia?
ReplyDeleteIt's the leaders of the society who consider the society as utopia, since they explain in chapter seventeen that they want to make their society feel comfort by taking soma. To us, as the reader, the society is dystopian, but in the point of view of the civilians that are taking soma see it as a comfortable society. I just wanted to explain why a utopian society, such as the one in the book, isn't really a hundred percent utopian, and people who are being brainwashed by being made, by the government, to take soma is a reason why the utopian society isn't fully utopian.
DeleteOk so you are saying that the people in the story believe they live in a utopia, however to us readers it is clearly a dystopia. I missed that point in the original post, thank you for further explaining that.
Delete